CANTORIAL COMMENTS

BY
CANTOR ELIHU FELDMAN

 

I COULD HAVE DANCED ALL NIGHT

 

Although Simchat Torah is not a biblical festival; it has turned into one of the most widely celebrated festivals in the Jewish year. The holiday has a liturgy if its own, with unique prayers, songs, music and traditions. While Simchat Torah focuses on the Torah as the beloved companion of our lives, the singing and dancing on Simchat Torah are reminiscent of wedding. As a bride and groom dancing with each other on their big night, so - on  Simchat Torah - we desire to hold the Sefer Torah in our arms and dance the night away.

 

Just when and where did the custom of singing and dancing develop? Jewish musiclogists belive that Simchat Torah developed during the Middle Ages and that the dancing and singing are part of a biblical commandment to “Rejoice on our Festivals.” Other musicologists provide a simple answer, stating that we are rejoicing in the completion of the Torah. Another opinion found though notes that the origin of making such a celebration upon completing the Torah stems all the way back from the time of King Solomon, who made a feast for all of his courtiers at the time of the dedication of the temple.

 

But the answer to why dancing and singing permeates Simchat Torah is not that simple. There were communities which wanted to abandon all singing, frivolity and dancing; based on the fact that the removal of the Torahs from the ark demanded a sense of respect and decorum. The Mishna Berurah , though,(O.C. 669) cites a statement of Maharik, who writes that it is not proper for us to forbid dancing and singing which have evolved for the celebration of Simchat Torah. As such, places that refrain from making it a day of celebration are not acting properly.

 

The liturgy of Simchat Torah evening is unique. The liturgical mode for the maariv (evening service) is that of the High Holydays and sounds very much like Yom Kippur or Rosh Hashonah evening. This motif may be consistent with the approach of those communities which adopted a more somber approach to Simchat Torah. At Ma'ariv (the evening service) on Simchat Torah eve, each member of the congregation recites a verse from"Ata Horeita" - a series of verses praising God   and the Torah. The ark is opened and all the Torah scrolls are removed. The person leading the hakaffah holds a Torah and recites a prayer, with the refrain "Hoshia Na" (Please Save Us). The other people holding the Sifrei Torah follow the leader as he circles the synagogue. It is customary for the rest of the congregation to kiss the Sifrei Torah as the procession passes by. The act of encircling the  synagogue (or the bima ) is called Hakafot (singular - Hakafah). After the procession has completed an entire hakafah, the congregation bursts out in joyous song and dance - the focus of all the festivities are the Sifrei Torah. An onlooker would see circles of jubilant frenzy, a muddle of people dancing with Sifrei Torah, children on parent's shoulders and brightly colored flags.

 

On the night preceding Simchat Torah and again the following morning ("they could've danced all night!"), Jews all over the world (in Israel, Shmini Atzeret and Simchat Torah are rolled into one) dance joyously with the Torah. Each dance is begun with a circuit of the bimah (the central platform in the synagogue from which the Torah is read), which symbolizes the altar in the Temple, by Jews carrying scrolls of the Torah taken from the Ark. This is done seven times, each to its own "lyrics," but all to a standard melody. This is followed by exuberant dancing, to the sound of various Hebrew melodies, ranging from the ancient to the old to the new, a capello (without instrumental accompaniment).

 

The songs are based mainly on phrases from the Bible, or the Talmud, or Jewish tradition, and the dances continue for an undetermined length of time, or until they are stopped by the Rabbi, for the purpose of allowing the congregants to get some rest, or until the dancers become exhausted, whichever comes first.

 

After a while, the first hakafah is completed, and the Torah scrolls given to other people - the procession then starts all over again. This process is repeated until there have been seven hakafot (and can continue late into the night). After the final hakafah, all the Sifrei Torah except for one are returned to the ark. Sections of the closing portion of the Torah VeZot HaBracha) are read, except for the last few lines. The Torah is returned and the service is concluded.

 

Possibly the most visible of all practices on Simchat Torah is that of Hakafot, the walking around the bima with the Torah. Several sources are given for this custom. Ramo says that the practice is to circle the bima while singing praises, and that this is done in imitation of the seven times that we circle the bima on Hoshana Rabba. The Mishna Berura also notes this as a reason, although he also notes that there are those who only circle the bima three times. Otzar Ta'amei Minhagim (by Shmuel David Gelberd) writes that seven hakafot is the custom of the Arizal, and is done either due to the link to Hoshana Rabba (as brought down by the Sha'arei Knesset HaGedolah) or as a reminder of the battle against Yericho, when the Jews circles the city seven times with the Ark containing the Torah.

 

Rav Shlomo Yoseif Zevin notes that the practice of hakafot at night, first appears in the customs of Rav Issac Tirana, while it is Ramo who first mentions doing so during the day. The practice of reciting the set of verses that begin with "Ata Har'eita" stems from the Machzor Vitri and Maharam MiRutenberg.

 

At the morning service, hakafot are repeated as the night before. Simchat Torah is a time for celebration! Won’t you please join us and make this year’s Simchat Torah celebration the best of all.

 

Sincerely,

 

Cantor Elihu Feldman